India, Russia may export 1,000 BrahMos 24 Jan 2007, 0005 hrs IST,Rajat Pandit,TNN Print Save EMail Write to Editor
NEW DELHI: The US used almost 800 cruise missiles for its attack on Iraq in 2003. Much cheaper and easier to operate than ballistic missiles, cruise missiles are rapidly becoming the preferred option to wage a war. So much so that there are around 80,000 cruise missiles in the inventories of 75 countries at this moment.
Keeping this "huge export potential" in mind, India and Russia now obviously want to rake in the moolah by selling at least 1,000 of the jointly-developed BrahMos supersonic cruise missiles to "friendly" countries in the near future. The export version will basically be the anti-ship variant of the 290-km range BrahMos, already inducted into Indian Navy. Incidentally, the land-attack, air and submarine-launched versions of BrahMos are also in the pipeline for the Indian armed forces now.
But in the run-up to Russian president Vladimir Putin and defence minister Sergei Ivanov's visit this week, there has been some wrangling over the issue of exports. India is keen to jumpstart the process, with the global cruise missile market estimated to be worth around $10 billion in the coming decade, but there has been opposition from some quarters in Russia.
Ivanov, however, clarified in Bangalore on Tuesday that Russia was not opposed to selling BrahMos to some "specific third countries". In Delhi, top Indian and Russian officials also dismissed reports that Moscow had reservations on the matter.
They, in fact, asserted that a supervisory council of the two governments had already identified the countries concerned. Though they were reluctant to name them, TOI has earlier reported that talks had been held with Malaysia, Chile, South Africa, Kuwait and UAE in this regard.
-------------------------------- 위에 푸른색 부분이 러시아는 인도가 어떤 나라에 팔던 상관하지 않겠다
라는 뜻으로 해석될수 있겠지만 그 밑을 보면 수출대상국가들은 암묵적으로 정해졌다..라고 봐도 무방할 듯 합니다.
그런데, 다른 기사를 찾아보니 이란이 이 미사일에 관심을 보인다고도 합니다.
http://www.indiadaily.com/editorial/16811.asp
India and Russia decide to start export the BrahMos missile by year-end to friendly countries - is Iran on the list? Sonia Joshi May 20, 2007
The first contract for the export of jointly developed Indo-Russian BrahMos cruise missile to a "friendly" country is in pipeline and could be inked by the end of 2007.
"First contract for the delivery of BrahMos cruise missiles to a friendly country is expected to be signed by the end of the year," CEO of the New Delhi-based BrahMos Aerospace Sivathanu Pillai said in Moscow.
International think tanks believe that Iran wants these BrahMos, to defend itself against Americans and Israelis. But it will be the biggest mistake for India. Islamic terrorists against India eventually can use these BrahMos one day.
------------------------------------------------- 이 기사의 경우 이란에게 파는 것에 대해서 경계하는 부분의 기사가 있기도 합니다. 아마도 이란에게 판매될 경우 어떻게 해서든 파키스탄 등 인도에
적대적인 이슬람단체에 흘러들어가면 인도가 뒷통수를 맞을 것이다란 소리겠죠.
여하튼....수출권에 대해서 러시아는 인도의 결정에 따르겠다는 입장입니다.
이런 일례를 놓고 볼때 한국이 러시아와 합작개발하게될 무기가 있다면 적어도 러시아제 부품을 사용하지 않는 방향으로 나가야 할 것으로 보입니다. 물론 한국과 러시아간의 무기개발 협력은 인도보단 조금 더 나아가
형태의 기술 도입을 통한 개발이기에 인도의 예가 꼭 맞는 것은 아닙니다. 게다가 국가마다 러시아가 취하는 액션도 틀리구요.
러시아와의 합작개발 무기의 수출권
한국이 러시아와 공동개발을 하는 것들이 몇개 있지만,
좀 낮은 수준의 공동개발을 먼저 놓고 볼때
비교대상이 될 만한 것이 인도-러시아 공동개발인
"브라모스" 초음속 미사일을 먼저 살펴보는 것이 좋을 것 같습니다.
브라모스 미사일은 러시아의 야크혼트 미사일을 기반으로 개발되었으며,
야크혼트보다 더 넓은 발사방식을 지원합니다.
개발/생산은 인도의 방갈로드에 설립된 조인트벤쳐 회사인 '브라모스'사를
통해 이뤄지며, 중요부품은 러시아에서 수입되긴 합니다.
우선 수출에 대해서 살펴보면, 아래 글을 보면 대외수출에 대한
러시아의 입장에 대해서 잘 나타나 있는 부분이 있습니다.
-----------------------------------------
http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/India_Russia_may_export_1000_BrahMos/articleshow/1410581.cms
India, Russia may export 1,000 BrahMos
24 Jan 2007, 0005 hrs IST,Rajat Pandit,TNN
Print Save EMail Write to Editor
NEW DELHI: The US used almost 800 cruise missiles for its attack on Iraq in 2003. Much cheaper and easier to operate than ballistic missiles, cruise missiles are rapidly becoming the preferred option to wage a war. So much so that there are around 80,000 cruise missiles in the inventories of 75 countries at this moment.
Keeping this "huge export potential" in mind, India and Russia now obviously want to rake in the moolah by selling at least 1,000 of the jointly-developed BrahMos supersonic cruise missiles to "friendly" countries in the near future. The export version will basically be the anti-ship variant of the 290-km range BrahMos, already inducted into Indian Navy. Incidentally, the land-attack, air and submarine-launched versions of BrahMos are also in the pipeline for the Indian armed forces now.
But in the run-up to Russian president Vladimir Putin and defence minister Sergei Ivanov's visit this week, there has been some wrangling over the issue of exports. India is keen to jumpstart the process, with the global cruise missile market estimated to be worth around $10 billion in the coming decade, but there has been opposition from some quarters in Russia.
Ivanov, however, clarified in Bangalore on Tuesday that Russia was not opposed to selling BrahMos to some "specific third countries". In Delhi, top Indian and Russian officials also dismissed reports that Moscow had reservations on the matter.
They, in fact, asserted that a supervisory council of the two governments had already identified the countries concerned. Though they were reluctant to name them, TOI has earlier reported that talks had been held with Malaysia, Chile, South Africa, Kuwait and UAE in this regard.
--------------------------------
위에 푸른색 부분이 러시아는 인도가 어떤 나라에 팔던 상관하지 않겠다
라는 뜻으로 해석될수 있겠지만
그 밑을 보면 수출대상국가들은 암묵적으로 정해졌다..라고 봐도 무방할 듯 합니다.
그런데, 다른 기사를 찾아보니 이란이 이 미사일에 관심을 보인다고도 합니다.
http://www.indiadaily.com/editorial/16811.asp
India and Russia decide to start export the BrahMos missile by year-end to friendly countries - is Iran on the list?
Sonia Joshi
May 20, 2007
The first contract for the export of jointly developed Indo-Russian BrahMos cruise missile to a "friendly" country is in pipeline and could be inked by the end of 2007.
"First contract for the delivery of BrahMos cruise missiles to a friendly country is expected to be signed by the end of the year," CEO of the New Delhi-based BrahMos Aerospace Sivathanu Pillai said in Moscow.
International think tanks believe that Iran wants these BrahMos, to defend itself against Americans and Israelis. But it will be the biggest mistake for India. Islamic terrorists against India eventually can use these BrahMos one day.
-------------------------------------------------
이 기사의 경우 이란에게 파는 것에 대해서 경계하는 부분의 기사가 있기도 합니다.
아마도 이란에게 판매될 경우 어떻게 해서든 파키스탄 등 인도에
적대적인 이슬람단체에 흘러들어가면 인도가 뒷통수를 맞을 것이다란 소리겠죠.
여하튼....수출권에 대해서 러시아는 인도의 결정에 따르겠다는 입장입니다.
이런 일례를 놓고 볼때 한국이 러시아와 합작개발하게될 무기가 있다면 적어도
러시아제 부품을 사용하지 않는 방향으로 나가야 할 것으로 보입니다.
물론 한국과 러시아간의 무기개발 협력은 인도보단 조금 더 나아가
형태의 기술 도입을 통한 개발이기에 인도의 예가 꼭 맞는 것은 아닙니다.
게다가 국가마다 러시아가 취하는 액션도 틀리구요.
과연 러시아는 한국을 어떤 대상으로 생각하고 있을까요?
제가 볼땐 인도보단 덜 매력적인 국가로 보고 있단 생각입니다만...